Showing posts with label MNC. Show all posts
Showing posts with label MNC. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 12, 2009

Don't you guys want to vote on the participants?

Senator Blutarsky, T Kyle, AuditDawg, et al, wouldn't this end of summer classic be made better by issuing ballots?

If it were left up to BCS supporters and college football traditionalists, Russia would probably be voted into this annual championship against East Germany.

Sorry, but I cannot pass up an opportunity to expose the utter ridicloulsness of the way we decide football D-1 championship.

If Jim Tressel had a vote, the Buckeyes would be in Williamsport. BUI!
Little League World Series Is a Can't-Miss Summer Event - Top Ten - NESN.com
It’s that time of year again, baseball fans, the time when the idea of watching 12-year-old phenoms tear up the diamond is too good to pass up.

Yep, it’s time for the Little League World Series, and everyone here at NESN is fired up for the regional coverage in Bristol, Conn. In fact, everyone in the country -- not just you baseball fans -- should have an interest in this annual event. Why? Because we’ve all played baseball, softball or some form of organized sports as youths, haven’t we? For those of you who haven’t, I feel for you.


Tuesday, August 11, 2009

Not too soon to brace yourself for another flawed National Championship game.

The Dawgs are hitting, the days are counting down, and my Google Reader is blowing up with unread stories.  Seems like the perfect time for me to go on another playoff rant.

While I might be among the majority of college football fans, I am certainly in the minority of Georgia bloggers on this issue.  The many obstacles standing in the way of a playoff have been noted over and over again. Most, if not all, of these obstacles are by design. They are there to protect the status quo. Heck, many of you reading this have been convinced that a program's revenue is more important than a legitimate shot at a winning a national championship.

Yes, we have the best regular season in all of sport. Yes, we have more tradition and history than most sports. Yes, this is how we have always done it. Yes, I believe championships should be decided on the field. No, I am not sold on the idea that a playoff would hurt Georgia financially. No, I do not think a two team playoff in which the participants are voted in qualifies as a true championship.

The current system, like most bureaucrocies, serves the weak at the expense of the strong. I recently saw a posting stating that any system that gets the Arizona Cardinals into the champioship game is a flawed system due to their weak regular season record.  My position is that their weak regular season record may be due to the competition they faced. After all, in the post season they whipped every team that came before them before ultimately losing to the Steelers in the Super Bowl.  What is wrong with that?

Tony Barnhardt spoke with Gary Danielson about the upcoming SEC season. The subject was not about a playoff, but this statement speaks volumes about the problems with the current BCS arrangement. Danielson: Georgia will be the surprise team of SEC | Mr. College Football
“I don’t think there is any doubt that it is separating itself because it will attract great players for the foreseeable future. But here is the danger and I started saying this three years ago. The future challenge for this league is that if the rules don’t change for playing for the national championship (only the top two in the BCS standings get in) it is going be more difficult for the SEC to keep winning national titles. These teams are going to be so good. Ole Miss is improving. Arkansas is improving. Auburn is going to come back. Tennessee is going to come back. Florida, Alabama, LSU, and Georgia are great programs. You’re going to have a bunch of teams with two losses and people are going to start thinking this is an average league. They would be wrong, but that will be the perception.

Right now the SEC has the benefit of everything going their way. They are going to win all tiebreakers. Their teams will be ranked higher at the beginning of the year and deservedly so. But does a one-loss SEC team jump ahead of an undefeated Big Ten team? As we move forward there is going to be tremendous pressure to put the undefeated teams in.

Things changed for the SEC when (No. 4) Florida jumped over (No. 3) Michigan in 2006 and played Ohio State for the national championship and won. Could they change again because the SEC gets so tough and really starts beating each other up? That’s the danger I see down the road.”


Monday, July 20, 2009

Take 2 Aspirin and Drink Plenty of Water


It was a busy weekend in Valdosta with a slew of family in town and lots of golf, including the British Open on the tube. Watching Watson was reminiscent of my childhood, only this time I was pulling for him. In the end, it wasn't meant to be, but here's to @StewartCink. His twitter updates on his troubles getting to Scotland and his carry-on luggage coming back have been priceless. Rex Robinson opines here.

Back to the typical mid-summer football oleo that leads up to the SEC Media Days.

Jim Donnan was inducted into College Football Hall of Fame. I was never a big Jim Donnan hater, except for that opener back in 96, but he won me over in the rain against Texas-Tech and I stayed with him through Columbia in 2000. Mark Bradley gives his take, as does Bill King with a bonus recap of the greatest wins of the Donnan era as he sees it.

Tim Tebow is not unanimous selection as All-SEC QB per coaches. Why wasn't Tebow unanimous? Darrell Owenby examines, along with a myriad of other columnists and bloggers. Personally, I find the pre-season All-SEC team about as worthy as a Hanoi Jane diatribe, but hey it is summer and look at all the thousands of words produced in July.

The Dawgs are starting to roll in the "Verbal Commitment" department. These commitments are not binding, but Mark Richt is beating the hell out of par in holding onto his "verbals". Kipp Adams gives a great review of "Dawg Night". Ohio State bemoans the loss of Garrison "Jeff Owens 2.0" Smith. Blutarsky ran a great piece on SEC spending on recruiting with Knoxville and West Opelika leading the way. Chris Low knows a good story when he reads one.

Things are happening on the hard court and this blogger likes what he sees. The coaching staff has been finalized as Westerdawg reports. Daugman informs us about Sundiata Gaines and his aspirations to become an Atlanta Hawk. If you are a basketball fan, please do yourself a favor and take some time to read over his site thoroughly, he really has his finger on the pulse of Coach Fox's team.

Team Speed Kills gives a brief look at the schedule for Media Days.

Finally, it has been said, putting a football playoff together for D-1 is not rocket science. Perhaps, early in 2010, President Obama and teleprompter will give an inspiring speech proclaiming that we will develop the technology and where with all to implement a post season tournament to decide a football champion on the gridiron free of the politics of personal destruction (voters wearing vest).

Thursday, July 9, 2009

Why we chant SEC! SEC! SEC! And you are The Rust Belt


A response to Luke @ Eleven Warriors, please give it a read.

Why do we chant "SEC"? In a word, pride. Pride in the level of competition. Pride in knowing our conference champ whipped your conference champ. No team in the country wants to beat Gainesville more than the Georgia Bulldogs. But I will be damned if I want some Big10 or Big12 team beating my conference champion in the MNC game, or any other for that matter. It does not surprise me a fan in Ohio does not understand this.

It also comes not as a shock our pioneering kinfolk, long since having left our beloved South to liberate the Big12 frontier, share our passionate support for their conferences’ athletic prowess. To state that the Big12 wants to dethrone the SEC is only stating the Big12 is ambitious, an admirable trait of most Americans. For an Ohioan to take offense is further evidence of the apathy that leads one’s region to be known as the rust belt.

Should it be expected, that from the land of Dennis Kucinich, a football blogger would talk of “narrow minded, xenophobic, regional fervor”. How about this jewel: “At the end of the day, it doesn’t matter if your conference hasn’t won a Rose Bowl in a decade or if they even have a BCS tie-in at all: a football’s a football flying at 30,000 feet and there are some 1500 unplayed games without predetermine outcomes still to transpire.”

My guess is fans of the Buckeye reserve pride for the regular season, for the Michigan game, or maybe the Toledo game. After reading Luke’s blog, I have a much greater understanding of the Big10’s desire to have their champion play in the Rose Bowl and the desire to play a Pac10 team in that Rose Bowl. For Luke, having to play a Big12 or SEC team in a bowl game is unlike the 1500 games without predetermined outcomes. Yes, in Lukes eyes, those outcomes, as if ordained by God, have already been decided.

We may be a tad fanatical to look upon the SEC Championship game as a National Semifinal. Surely, something must be wrong with me, a Georgia man without a national football title in the last 28 years. How can I have higher expectations, more pride, than a Buckeye blogger with multiple conference titles and a national championship in the current decade? This is an evolutionary question for which I have no answer.

The one thing I can assure Luke, be it the BCS Title game, the Sugar Bowl, Captial One, Outback, or any other field of play, when time has expired and the Bulldogs have emerged triumphant, at some point the chant will begin. SEC! SEC! SEC!

Wednesday, July 8, 2009

A Plan for BCS Equity in a Playoff

BigXII vs. SEC

Sugar Bowl

Semifinal 1
Rotating BCS Site
Big East vs. ACC

Orange Bowl


Championship Game
Rotating BCS Site
Big10 vs. Pac10

Rose Bowl

Semifinal 2
Rotating BCS Site
NonBCS* vs. AtLarge**

Fiesta Bowl




































*The Non-BCS conferences form their own organization to determine their entrants into the BCS tournament. They can sell the television rights, etc.
**The pollsters and computers retain their contribution by selecting the At-Large entrant, the highest ranked non-automatic birth as determined by the current BCS ranking process.

Pros:

  • The current BCS cities and their Bowl organization’s get to keep their game plus and extra game 3 out of 4 years. I cannot see their local chambers of commerce complaining about that.
  • Television gets more programming with less competition. Imagine Semi-final Saturday!
  • Big10 and Pac10 get to keep their traditional Rose Bowl match up.
  • Television contract grows. I can see Roy Kramer coming out of retirement to sell this thing to the highest bidder.
  • Participant’s payouts grow as they advance. This means more academic and Title IX funding, or whatever. I am sure the university presidents will have no problem spending it.

Cons:

  • Harm to non-BCS bowls. This argument was also made when the BCS was created. I am not buying it.
  • Season is too long. They have been making this argument for years. Only 4 teams would be required to play extra games with the exception of a play-in system for non-BCS conference champs. Florida played 14 games last year. This system would have required them to play 16 if the 12 game regular season remains. This is a stumbling block due to departments budgeting that 12th game in indefinitely.
  • Impact on Academics, please. If the basketball “student-athletes” can do it I believe the football players will manage.
  • Scheduling, starting before Jan 1 would be a big problem, competing with NFL Saturday playoff games in January would have to be addressed.

Conclusion:

Obviously, this is not a comprehensive plan, please consider it a "Plus 3" from 40k feet. I have tried to address the core points made by opponents to a playoff. In my opinion the institutional opposition is mainly about control and finances. This system allows the BCS conferences to retain control and the lion’s share of the pie. History and tradition, very integral parts of college football, simply cannot be overcome. I would like to point out, however, that the Rose Bowl has survived, as has the 3rd Saturday in October. Incremental change has been a constant in college football and the game is stronger than ever. Now, let’s make that last push and finally decide a legitimate champion of the football field.

Tuesday, July 7, 2009

Is Senator Blutarsky Softening his pro-BCS Stance?


Senator Blutarsky would probably say I am taking his statements out of context, or perhaps fall back on another Washingtonian phrase, “I have no recollection of having blogged that.”

In his blog titled “The most Reasonable man in College Football” (I love the irony) the good Senator states:

“By the way, the play-in game is an excellent idea. In fact, I like it better than the automatic berth for the highest ranked non-BCS conference school.”

He then attempts to tie this in to his protectionist stance by stating it would not take money out of any other conferences pockets. But I will focus on the positive.

To be fair, the context of the Senator’s statement regards participation of non-BCS conference schools in the BCS revenue windfall and has nothing to do with using a “play-in” game to determine a champion. However, if the Senator has come to realize a play-in game is good for the #8 spot in the BCS he must be trending toward a play-in game for both of the finalist. This is how God intended sport to be.

Progress is made incrementally in our society; therefore I will chalk this one up as a win for those of us that believe championships should be won on the field without assist from the body politic.

The BCS debate will not go away

One of the best Georgia Football blogs out there is Get The Picture. Senator Blutarsky does an excellent job of producing and gathering fine content for the Bulldawg Nation and college football fans in general. The Senator is an ardent supporter of the BCS and today he takes a shot at John Feinstein for supporting a true playoff.

I urge you to read his original post and the arguments/comments here.

My response:

I am no Feinstein apologist, but perhaps the demand for football is greater than basketball, regardless of post-season format. Surely the Senator is not implying basketball could bring in more money if they would dump the "brackets" for some pageant style bowl system such as the BCS...

Does anybody out there believe the SEC regular season, with all of its conference title implications, would be diminished if second teams from the SEC made some type of NCAA run championship tourney as an at-large bid?

I understand this is the system we are stuck with. Furthermore, I understand the financial implications to change, but these implications would be most felt by outside interests.

The BCS has, more often than not, produced a quality match up for deciding the MNC. However, it also produces Hawaii v. Dawgs. It is always fun to watch the Globetrotters trounce the Generals, but wouldn’t it be nice to see how they stack up against a quality opponent? Does anyone believe D-1 basketball should adopt a BCS style post-season?